The objective of this paper is to select a qualitative research article that is nursing based and that will be useful in future nursing practice. The article, “Deliberate Practice of Motor Skills in Nursing Education: CPR as Exemplar” by Oermann et al. (2011), explores the effects of strict practice to retain proper skills of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) among nursing students. This study investigates the difference in nursing students who have consistent practice of CPR skills and those that only attend an initial CPR training (Oermann et al., 2011).
Research Question and Hypothesis
The authors suggest that CPR skills are quickly lost after the initial training if the skills are not used. Students who practice CPR six minutes a month for one year will perform better than those who take only the initial training with no follow up practice sessions. Life-saving and high-use skills need practice to improve their performance and develop expertise (Oermann et al., 2011).
Review of the Literature
This research confirmed prior research that had been taken. Repetitive practice and feedback will allow students to perform their skills more accurately. The skills will become automatic and will be done without thinking about them. The proper feedback will guide the student to perform and adjust their skills until they become consistent (Oermann et al., 2011).
Internal, External Validity and Research Design
This research article follows a quantitative approach with a randomized control trial. Six-hundred and six nursing students from 10 different nursing schools in the United States participated in the study (Oermann et al., 2011). All the students attended an initial CPR training and practiced their CPR skills on a Resusci Anne adult manikin. The students are then placed in one of two groups which are randomly selected to either the intervention or control group. The intervention group participates in a short six-minute practice session with a voice advisory manikin (VAM) one time a month for one year. The control group did not receive additional training after the initial CPR class. All of the participants returned to the nursing school laboratory where they received an envelope which indicated if there were to be reassessed on their skills or continue on in the study. Each school that participated in the study had site coordinators that implemented the study per protocol. They did not teach the students directly; they were guided by using the VAM. Once a student was reassessed, they are no longer needed in the study since the reassessment is considered practicing (Oermann et al., 2011).
The intervention group and the control group are predominantly females, with only 16% being males. The mean age of the nursing students is 28.4 years old. The study states that a few students had previously practiced CPR No other differences were noted between the two groups (Oermann et al., 2011).
The Institutional Review Board of the principal investigator’s university approved the research study. This study was considered a multi-site study to gain extensive information on a topic that has limited research. Each student provided written consent to participate. The VAM made the instruction free of bias (Oermann et al., 2011).
Data Collection Methods and Procedures
The intervention group practiced adult CPR for six minutes per month for one year. They performed two minutes of compressions, two minutes of ventilations, followed by two minutes of CPR. The VAM provides feedback at the time of practice. Notifying the students in the compression depth and breaths are adequate. Data from the reassessment was collected at 3,6,9, and 12 months (Oermann et al., 2011).
Reliability and Validity
The research study follows the American Heart Association (AHA) 2005 guidelines. Which states the proper depth for compressions and the adequate volume for ventilations. Using the VAM and no other form of instruction gave the study consistency. The VAM was able to measure the volume of ventilation and depth of compressions to provide consistency in collecting data from all the universities in the study (Oermann et al., 2011).
Linear mixed models were used to document both the intervention and control group during the initial BLS training and reassessments. They were compared at the reassessment time using the student’s baseline from the initial training (Oermann et al., 2011).
Conclusions, Implications, and Recommendations
The research indicated that at the end of the one-year study the control group compressed more times than the control group, but the depth of the compressions was considerably less. The control group who had practiced six minutes per month with the VAM improvement in their skills. The reassessment of ventilation skills showed that the intervention group maintained their performance. Ventilation skills in the control group significantly decreased over the one-year time frame. Students that practice their CPR skills on VAMs which provide feedback maintained or improved their skills over the 12 months (Oermann et al., 2011).
Application to Nursing Practice
Continuous training on nursing skills will make the skill become automatic. The study emphasizes the need for continuous education to make motor learning permanent and retained for use in the future. The study shows that when a skill is new even lapsing a month can diminish your accuracy of the skill. (Oermann et al., 2011).
- Oermann, M., Edgren, S., Odom-Maryon, T., Hallmark, B., Hurd, N., Rogers, N., McMolgan, J., Snelson, C., Dowdy, S., Resurreccion, L., Kuerschner, D., LaMar, J., Tennant, M., & Smart, D. (2011). Deliberate practice of motor skills in nursing education: CPR as exemplar. Teaching with Technology, 32,(5), 311-315
Cite This Work
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
Related ServicesView all
Related ContentAll Tags
Content relating to: "CPR"
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation is a “combination of oral resuscitation (mouth-to-mouth breathing), which supplies oxygen to the lungs, and external cardiac massage (chest compression), which is intended to normalise cardiac function and blood circulation.
Bystander Intervention in Improving Survival Changes of CPR
Pre-Hospital Care On Scene Time. In response to a call for a possible cardiac arrest, the time that it takes for first responders to arrive on scene greatly influences the survival rate of those...
Literature Review and Annotated Bibliography: Importance of Improving Health Providers CPR Skills, Knowledge and Confidence
The purpose of this study was to examine the effectiveness of brief practice of single rescuer BLS on VAMs (voice advisory manikin) in retaining skills compared to a control group with no practice beyond their initial training....
DMCA / Removal Request
If you are the original writer of this literature review and no longer wish to have your work published on the NursingAnswers.net website then please: